Search for Homes in New Town

New Town Homes for Sale

New Town in Key West, Florida, offers some truly remarkable advantages to its residents. This extraordinary community is bordered by the water and by Mid Town, as well as being the closest neighborhood to U.S. Highway 1, the island’s connection to the mainland. Among the multitude of amenities found within this distinguished area, you’ll find Dry Tortugas Kayak Rental, Southernmost Kitchen and Bath, Winn Dixie, Publix, Walgreens, CVS and Home Depot. This eastern part of the island also boasts a number of exciting recreation opportunities at destinations including Subtropic Dive Center, Charter Boat Rides, Sunset Watersports and the Key West Resort Golf Course. Speaking of golf, this Rees Jones designed 18-hole par-70 course touts itself as the country’s southernmost golf course and is a must-see for visitors and residents alike.

Adding to its allure, New Town is also home to the Civil War-era Fort East Martello Museum and Gallery and its 8-foot thick walls and plethora of military memorabilia and historic artifacts. Additionally, the neighborhood has a movie theater and a handful of restaurants from which to choose. With its idyllic location and its many options for shopping, recreation, entertainment, and dining, New Town is a fabulous place to buy a home.

Homes for sale in New Town are typically older, having been built in the 1950s and 1960s, however, there are some exceptions. New Town properties also tend to be larger than average and boast generous yards which make the community a great place for families or people who enjoy entertaining. It is also not uncommon for New Town real estate to have gorgeous terrazzo floors, and compared to homes in Old Town, they are very affordable. Prospective homebuyers desiring a peaceful island lifestyle in a primarily residential area should definitely consider the homes for sale in New Town. If you would like to learn more about available real estate in New Town of Key West, Florida, please allow us to assist you and contact us today.

New Town's Newest Listings

$1,450,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 601609 MLS
Four bedroom oasis on Eagle Ave:Located in the heart of one of Key West's most upscale and quiet neighborhoods you will find 3509 Eagle Avenue. As you open the white picket fence and make your way through the home's main entrance you will find an oversized and flexible entry foyer, currently a home office and music room. This room is only the beginning of this beautifully maintained 4- bedroom 3-bathroom gem. The main home boasts 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, while the private guest cottage offers an additional 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom. An expansive great room is the centerpiece of the main home. Crisp white walls perfect for art lovers an open concept kitchen with built-in breakfast nook / dining area and a rich blue backsplash bring character to the space. This layout makes it easy to entertain guests or sit in the cozy banquette and enjoy a cup of coffee gazing out onto the front yard. Natural light fills the home and views of tropical splendor are enjoyed through many of the windows. The Master Bedroom features sliding glass doors that lead you to the outside deck that steps down to an expansive 7,920 square foot lot surrounded and filled with lush native tropical foliage and mature landscaping. This fenced-in backyard offers enough room for a pool with plenty of privacy. Off- Street parking for four cars, a first class location, an indoor washer & dryer are a few of the features that make this the perfect Key West home! Available to view Sunday, July 3rd from 12-3.

3509 Eagle, Key West

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Knight & Gardner Realty.

$995,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 601581 MLS
This New Town Key West home has it all from a large fully fenced 6800 square foot lot to a large pool plus it is elevated, comes fully furnished and has hurricane impact windows throughout. Close to shopping, restaurants and schools, this 3 bedroom/2 bath home's rear gate opens to Cozumel Park with children's water park. There is plenty of off street parking with a carport in this quiet family neighborhood.

1018 18th, Key West

Listing courtesy of Century 21 All Keys Inc (Kw).

$899,999
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 601528 MLS
Centrally located in Key West, you'll find this charming 3 Bedroom/2 Bath home that has just over 1,100 sq. Ft. of living space and sits on a 5,700 sq. ft. lot. Just minutes from many of Key Wests shopping centers, schools, government centers, beaches and much more. Upon entering the home you will find a great open floor plan & a recently renovated kitchen with plenty of space for entertaining family & friends. Just off the living room you will find sliding glass doors that allow for lots of natural light and leads you to your large backyard where there is room for a pool and even a shed that offers more storage or could possibly be converted to an additional bedroom. A few of the updates include a newer metal roof, stainless steel appliances, quartz counter tops, built in cabinetry & new lightning. Additionally the property has a great size laundry room & covered parking!

3618 Northside, Key West

Listing courtesy of Truman & Co. (Kw).

$1,699,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 601508 MLS
This could be YOUR new Back yard! Not a drive by- way bigger than it looks! Wonderful and rare WATERFRONT 5 BEDROOM home with great boating access right in Key West! Fabulous canal front home with concrete dockage, convenient step down, and boatlift with both gulf and ocean access. Updated kitchen with custom cabinetry and Corian countertops, with a large combination pantry and laundry area. This sturdy concrete home has a very nice flowing floor plan. The backyard is fenced and includes a hot tub, an awesome entertainment area and a large separate building that would be a perfect mother-in law conversion but is currently used as a versatile storage/loft area . This would be a perfect home for an extended family or two family ownership. Convenient location for beaches and shopping. Updates include electrical and heat/AC, windows and exterior doors, and a propane gas water heater. Of course there is room for a pool!

1615 Venetian, Key West

Listing courtesy of Broker's Edge Realty, Inc..

$999,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 601503 MLS
Centralized location, 4 BR & 2.5 BA home with a private inground swimming pool. Spacious family/bonus room opens onto the backyard pool area with an elevated deck, outdoor shower and mature landscaping. Hardwood cabinetry, granite counter tops & stainless-steel appliances. There is a 1 BR & 1 BA suite, with a private entrance, as an office or for separate living. The oversized 6200+ sq. ft. lot has a gated fenced yard & off-street parking.

2808 Staples, Key West

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Knight & Gardner Realty.

$1,150,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 601472 MLS
World Class Resort. Top floor Pool views from your unit. Your own Private observation deck with water views. 3 Bedrooms and 3 Bathrooms. Granite counter tops, marble floors, large kitchen, stainless steel appliances, fully furnished, huge Master Bedroom. Your property is accented with luxurious finishes! Enjoy this property for yourself or take advantage of the amazing rental income potential. Private Beach, Waterfront Pool, Hot Tub, Parking, Top Rated Restaurant, fitness center, spa, valet parking, poolside bar, downtown shuttle, ballrooms, helicopter pad and so much more! Won't last long!

3841 N Roosevelt Unit 232, Key West

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co. (Kw).

$598,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 601435 MLS
Enjoy tropical breezes off your deck or second story balcony, surrounded by tropical landscaping and privacy fence. Immaculate 2 BR/1 -1/2 BA home with a huge den/3rd bedroom option, carport and additional off street parking. Impact doors, newer roof and appliances, large attached storage room with electricity, are just a few of the amenities this centrally located charmer offers. Close to shopping and restaurants. Won't last long! Owner is a Fl licensed Realtor.

3214 Eagle, Key West

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate Co. (Kw).

$949,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 601432 MLS
Welcome Home! This charming home has a great cozy feel that is warm and inviting. The main living area has 3BR/2.5BA with an open layout, private ambiance and a spacious front porch. The large backyard has an entertaining deck that is ideal for gatherings. The stunning mature landscaping contains many specimen trees with private areas for relaxation. In addition, there is an attractive artist cottage with vaulted ceilings that is sure to inspire some creative thoughts. Additional features include two outdoor showers ,ample storage, off street parking for multiple cars , RV or a boat. The yard is completely fenced for privacy. A must see for the discerning buyer!

2919 Seidenberg, Key West

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty.

$1,500,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 601336 MLS
This is the one! Pool, Boat access, Three (3) bedrooms and Two (2) Bathrooms with a pool house, and vacant ready for the new owners.This is just a perfect opportunity to move right into your Key West Paradise. A very well laid out home with plenty of room to entertain or just lay by the pool and watch the day just drift away. Want to go out on the boat? No problem, it's just sitting in your backyard ready to go. No storage fees, or marina fees and just very easy to set up your sunset cruise or day fishing trip.One of the best neighbors in all of the Florida Keys -- very family friendly as the street has a dead end at the end of it. Minimal traffic on this street. A wonderful house in a special place, called Key West. Make it yours today. Call for your private showing.*The Property is subject to an Ancillary Probate proceeding in Monroe County, Florida. An order authorizing the sale of the Property will be required as a condition of the Sale.*

1714 Bahama, Key West

Listing courtesy of Coastal Collection Real Estate Inc..

$5,100
1 Baths ⋅ 601314 MLS
Retail Space available in one of Key West's three major power centers. Overseas Market boasts one of the most desirable tenant bases on the island with Winn-Dixie, Denny's, Ross, CVS Drugstores, Verizon, GNC, Goldman's Deli, BodyZone, AutoZone, Five Guys, Dominos, Quest and more... There is ample parking & traffic light entry into the shopping center. Monthly rent quoted is Base Rent Only, in addition are triple net charges and sales tax. Available July 1st 2022

2816 N Roosevelt, Key West

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Knight & Gardner Realty.

$1,000,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 601315 MLS
Spacious four bedroom, four bath nearly 2400 square foot home on a 6800 square foot lot! This home features expansive living spaces. Kitchen offers granite countertops & stainless steel appliances, plenty of cabinet space, and a built-in desk space. There is a formal dining area, French doors off kitchen lead to great room with space for dining and lounging with poolside views from the picture window and sliding glass doors. Primary suite bathroom offers a walk-in closet, en suite modern bath with floating vanity and glass shower. Features POOL, plantation shutter blinds, central AC, laundry room, ceramic tile, patio area for entertaining, & more! Rear gate opens to Cozumel park! Conveniently located to shopping centers, restaurants, and schools. Pool resurfaced in 2022.

1012 18th, Key West

Listing courtesy of Bascom Grooms Real Estate (Kw).

$950,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 601297 MLS
Fully fenced oversized corner lot in New Town and room for your toys! This two bedroom / one bath home (with outdoor toilet and shower) is tastefully appointed, cozy, and ready to move in. Impact windows and doors offer peace of mind and security for you and your family. Delightful outdoor living area is private with a custom dip pool and water feature and just right for entertaining. There's an outbuilding ideal as a private and secluded space - perfect as a woman- or man cave or hobby room! The owner even made for himself a putting green on the roof!:-) In addition to pictures, please take the Immersive Tour, and you may find it's all you need to translate your dream of a home in Paradise into your personal reality!

1313 8th, Key West

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty.

$1,290,000
6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 601311 MLS
This property is a rare opportunity to own a single family home with a detached duplex. The elevated main house, with two bedrooms and two baths, is perfect for an owners unit. Recent renovations include new floors, split-system HVAC, second bath addition, and other finishing touches. Located on a city fire lane, the rear house also has off-street parking and beautiful private tropical gardens. Totally separate is a legal duplex, each with two bedrooms and one bath. The interiors are modest with loads of private outdoor space for the tenants. Key West address with income. Who could ask for more?

1908 Roosevelt, Key West

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Key West Compass Realty.

$1,750
1 Baths ⋅ 601245 MLS
Newly updated and bright office/commercial space for lease in New Town, Key West and centrally located and within Walking distance to Wells Fargo, Publix and more. Offering 364sqf on the second floor with central Ac, half bath, private storage and ample off street parking for clients. Monthly rent includes electric, waters, sewer and common/exterior maintenance. Offered at $1750 + Sales tax. Building is shared with 3 other commercial spaces and professionals.

3152 Northside Unit C2, Key West

Listing courtesy of Coastal Collection Real Estate Inc..

$1,300
0 Baths ⋅ 601239 MLS
Professional office building, join the friendly business environment at the 12th Street Professional Plaza catering to a diversity of innovative businesses and entrepreneurs centrally located in New Town, perfect for government, medical, legal or any other professional use. This building offers adequate off-street parking, common lobby with elevator and restrooms. Unit 109-B will be demised from office 108 and includes two rooms, possibly convert the smaller room into a private restroom, approximately ~270sq.ft. of office space. Monthly rent quoted includes water, electric, base rent and CAM, in addition is applicable sales tax.

1111 12th Unit 109-B, Key West

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Knight & Gardner Realty.